Best Pizza in New York: Slice-by-Slice Guide for Pizza Lovers

If New York had an official city anthem, it might just be the sound of a pizza box opening. The city’s love affair with pizza is legendary, and if you’re on a mission to find the best pizza in New York, prepare yourself for a journey filled with melted cheese, perfect crusts, and debates that could rival political arguments.

Everyone has their favorite spot, and in this guide, we’re going to explore the classics and the downright drool-worthy slices you must try. Thanks to cheap flights to New York, you don’t have to just read about it – you can book a ticket and taste it fresh out of the oven.

This guide takes you through some of the most iconic, mouth-watering pizza spots that will make you crave that first cheesy bite:

1. Joe’s Pizza – A Timeless Classic

If there’s one place that consistently tops every list of the best pizza in New York, it’s Joe’s Pizza. Founded in 1975, this Greenwich Village institution is famous for its thin, crispy yet foldable slices – the true New York style. It’s the kind of pizza where you take one bite and suddenly understand why New Yorkers are so picky about their slices.

Tourists, locals, and even celebrities stop here for what many call the most famous pizza in NYC. While you’re there, notice the walls covered with photos of Joe with A-listers – proof that even Hollywood can’t resist a good New York slice.

Address: 7 Carmine Street, New York, NY 10014.

2. Di Fara Pizza – Brooklyn’s Pizza Royalty

Head over to Midwood, Brooklyn, and you’ll find Di Fara – a family-run gem that’s been serving arguably the best pizza in New York for decades. The late Dom DeMarco, who founded it in 1965, crafted every single pizza himself for over 50 years.

This spot is also a contender for the best pizza in the world, according to many pizza fanatics. Expect a bit of a wait, but trust us – when you’re holding that piping-hot slice topped with fresh basil and olive oil, you’ll forget all about the queue.

Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230.

3. Lombardi’s – America’s First Pizzeria

If you want to taste history, Lombardi’s in Little Italy is a must. Open since 1905, it’s credited as the first pizzeria in the United States. Their coal-oven pies have that perfect smoky char, topped with tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella.

Some call it the famous pizza in New York that started it all, and biting into a slice here is like taking a step back in time – only much more delicious.

Address: 32 Spring Street (at Mott St), New York, NY 10012.

Also Read: 7 Best Street Foods to Try in Hong Kong During Your Trip

4. Prince Street Pizza – The Square Slice King

In Nolita, Prince Street Pizza has turned the humble square slice into a superstar. Their Spicy Spring slice, loaded with thick pepperoni cups that crisp at the edges, is an Instagram sensation for a reason. Many claim it’s the most popular pizza in New York right now – and your taste buds will probably agree.

Address: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012.

5. John’s of Bleecker Street – No Slices, Just Pies

For those who believe pizza is best shared (or hoarded for yourself), John’s of Bleecker Street is a dream. No slices here – you get the whole pie, fresh out of the brick oven. Founded in 1929, this spot delivers that smoky, chewy, cheese-pull perfection that defines the best pizza in New York. Are you on the search of 10 Hottest New York Restaurants to make your taste buds feel wow?

Address: 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014.

Get your US visa online with early appointment dates and start your New York pizza trip sooner.

6. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza – A Creamy Twist

Not all NYC pizza is about tomato sauce and mozzarella. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza has made waves with their creamy, indulgent artichoke slice – a rich, cheesy, almost lasagna-like experience.

It’s one of the best pizzas to eat in New York if you’re in the mood for something bold and unforgettable. Be warned: one slice is often enough to fill you up completely. And if you’re planning to stay nearby, some of the best hotels in New York are just a short walk away, making it easy to enjoy this iconic spot without straying far from your room.

Address: 321 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003.

Must Read: Indian Food Recipes by Region: Iconic Dishes with Recipes!

7. Totonno’s – A Brooklyn Treasure

Coney Island might be famous for hot dogs, but it’s also home to Totonno’s, a pizzeria that’s been around since 1924. Their coal-fired pies are a lesson in balance – thin, crispy crust, perfectly seasoned sauce, and just the right amount of cheese.

For many locals, it’s the best pizza Brooklyn has to offer, and worth the subway ride all the way to the ocean.

8. Napoli Pizza – The Italian Heart of NYC

For those craving a taste of Naples, Napoli Pizza New York serves authentic Neapolitan pies with that irresistible wood-fired char. With soft, pillowy dough and fresh toppings, it’s a little slice of Italy in the middle of the Big Apple.

It’s also a great way to explore the type of pizza in New York that goes beyond the classic thin crust.

Times Square Pizza Spots – Quick Slices in the Heart of the City

Try a late-night slice at one of the many corner spots boasting the best pizza in New York Times Square. It’s touristy, yes, but sometimes you just need that quick, greasy goodness between Broadway shows. And if you want to make the most of your trip, many New York tour packages include food tours that let you taste these iconic slices.

Pizza Tips for Your NYC Trip

• The cost of pizza in New York varies widely – from $1 for a street slice to $25+ for a high-end artisan pie.
• Always fold your slice in half for the authentic New York eating style.

The Final Slice

Whether you’re after the smoky char of a coal oven, the pillowy crust of Neapolitan style, or the quick grab of a $1 slice, the search for the best pizza in New York is part of what makes visiting this city so addictive.

So grab a slice (or five) – your taste buds will thank you later!

FAQs- Best Pizza in New York

What is the most famous New York style pizza?
The most famous New York–style pizza is often considered Joe’s Pizza, known for its thin, foldable slices, perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, and decades-long legacy. It’s practically a rite of passage for pizza lovers visiting NYC.

What is the #1 pizza in the US?
While rankings change, Pepperoni pizza consistently tops the charts as the #1 most ordered and loved pizza in the US, with New York–style pepperoni slices being especially iconic.

Which NYC pizza won best in the world?
In recent competitions, Una Pizza Napoletana in Manhattan has been named the “Best Pizza in the World” by 50 Top Pizza, making it a global sensation.

Why is Joe’s pizza so famous in NYC?
Joe’s Pizza became legendary for its no-frills, perfect New York–style slices, served fresh from the oven since 1975. It’s been featured in movies, loved by celebrities, and praised for sticking to tradition.

What is classic NYC pizza?
Classic NYC pizza is a large, thin-crust slice with a crisp bottom, gooey mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and the ability to fold it in half while eating.

Why is New York famous for pizza?
New York is famous for pizza due to its immigrant history, decades of perfecting the craft, and even the city’s unique mineral-rich tap water, which many claim gives the dough its unmatched texture and flavor.

What is the most ordered pizza in America?
Pepperoni pizza holds the crown as the most ordered pizza in America, and New York–style pepperoni slices are among the most popular versions.

Who won the best pizza in the US?
Tony’s Pizza Napoletana in San Francisco has been awarded the title of “Best Pizza in the US” multiple times, but New York’s Una Pizza Napoletana remains a strong competitor on the global stage.

If You are a Foodie, You May Love This:

Street Food in India: So Good, Even 5-Star Chefs Are Taking Notes
Explore Food in Abu Dhabi: From Traditional Cuisine to Street Food
9 Of The Most Amazing Asian Food Cities For Eating Out

---

Akbar Travels Services

Best Flight Deals

Mumbai to Delhi Flight Tickets | Mumbai to Bangalore Flight Tickets | Kolkata to Mumbai Flight Tickets | Kochi to Abu Dhabi Flight Tickets | Lucknow to Riyadh Flight Tickets | Delhi to Ahmedabad Flight Tickets

Domestic Flights

Pune to Bangalore Flights | Chennai to Delhi Flights | Bangalore to Chennai Flights | Mumbai to Delhi Flights | Bangalore to Hyderabad Flights | Ahmedabad to Goa Flights | Mumbai to Kolkata Flights | Hyderabad to Delhi Flights | Bangalore to Goa Flights | Mumbai to Goa Flights

International Flights

International Flights Booking | Delhi to Dubai Flights | Delhi to Bangkok Flights | Delhi to Toronto Flights | Mumbai to Dubai Flights | Delhi to Singapore Flights | Delhi to London Flights | Delhi to Kathmandu Flights | Mumbai to London Flights | Chennai to  Singapore Flights | Mumbai to Singapore Flights | Delhi to New York Flights | Kolkata to Bangkok Flights

Best Hotel Deals

Hotels In Dubai | Hotels In Mumbai India | Hotels In Pune India | Hotels In Singapore | Hotels In Kochi India | Hotels In Munnar India | Hotels In Bangkok Thailand | Hotels In Kuala Lumpur Malaysia | Hotels In Mecca Saudi Arabia | Hotels In Mahabalipuram India

Apply Visa Online

Dubai Visa Online | 14 days Dubai Visa | 30 days Dubai Visa | 60 days Dubai Visa | Dubai Transit Visa | UAE Visa | Singapore Visa | Malaysia Visa | Thailand Visa | Sri Lanka Visa | US Visa | UK Visa | Schengen Visa | Canada Visa | Australia Visa | New Zealand Visa | France Visa | Italy Visa | Turkey Visa Online | Philippines Visa | Cambodia Visa Online | Vietnam Visa Online | Oman Visa 

International Tour Packages

Dubai Tour Packages | Singapore Tour Packages | Thailand Tour Packages | Malaysia Tour Packages | Sri Lanka Tour Packages | US Tour Packages | United Kingdom Tour Packages | South Africa Tour Packages | Europe Tour Packages | Bali Tour Packages | Mauritius Tour Packages | Maldives Tour Packages | Cordelia Cruise Packages |

Domestic Tour Packages

India Tour Packages | Goa Tour Packages | Kerala Tour Packages | Leh Ladakh Tour Packages | Himachal Tour Packages | Andaman Tour Packages | Rajasthan Tour Packages | Uttarakhand Tour Packages | Jammu and Kashmir Tour Packages

Packages by Themes

Honeymoon Packages | Adventure Packages | Visa on Arrival Packages | Family Packages | Romantic Packages | Weekend Getaways Packages